Before I joined the police service, I read a lot in preparation for the interview. One book that I found absolutely fascinating was “ Bent Coppers” a history of Corruption in the British Police Service. Having seen the cover, I expected to find it written by a John Lennon look alike who labored under the impression that all Police Officers were in fact Neanderthal neo fascists who had trouble reading without moving their lips and spent their time (in-between Lodge Meetings) fitting up innocent members of this weeks ethnic minority of choice. That I expected this shows also something of my own preconceptions at the time, (or, dare I say, prejudice) I was, despite having a masters degree in a liberal arts subject, under the impression that anyone who was in any way “ social “ (e.g. commentator/ worker etc) automatically used unscented soap, knitted their own musseli, wore National Health glasses, and was a fully paid up member of CND and the communist party. Like most preconceptions they were wrong. The book was clearly written, and informative and in the main body of the text largely non-judgmental, it was however the epilogue that will always remain with me, (it must be remembered that this was in the days before Lord McPherson put the final nail in the coffin of British policing). The conclusion of the book was (I do not remember the exact words and I gave away my copy), but the gist any way was: “ the British Public must decide weather it wants to be protected by a Police force that is effective but occasionally does not bear too close examination, or would prefer to be left defenseless and have a squeaky clean Police force that looked good and acheaved little”.
After my first two weeks in the force I was in a classroom that was addressed by a man whom I consider to be the Messiah of Modern Policing, the then Chief Constable of Kent, Dave Philips. Dave Philips was a blunt Yorkshire man, with a mind that was anything but blunt, a visionary, and like most prophets a man unheralded in his own land. The class of which I formed a part had just been subjected to two weeks of Intense Political Correctness, lessons on stereotyping, and other political buzzwords and then there was Dave Philips. I would like to say that rolls of thunder heralded his entrance, blistering lightening lit the sky and that the curtains of the lecture hall were rent in two. However in the interests of veracity I cannot, it was spring in Kent and birds were twittering almost annoyingly outside. Dave Philips entered, wild grey hair flying, suit sleeves rolled up to the elbow and wearing the most incongruous white socks.
It is not often that one can recall the contents of a speech many years after the event, however, Dave Phillips (to the evident dismay of our immaculate instructors) launched into a speech on the insights of the First world war historian and writer Liddell Heart, and then proceeded to advise the raw recruits that stereo typing works. “As an avid ornithologist”, he told us “ I see a nightingale and hear it’s song, I do this on a number of occasions, when on a later occasion I hear the same song but I can not see the bird I can rest assured that there is a nightingale present”. I remember watching the instructors groan at this patiently obvious piece of common sense that so went against what they were trying to teach. Dave Philips was (in his own words) “ A f*cking good detective” for the simple reason that he understood human beings and was not afraid to act on that understanding. This of course placed a glass ceiling on his career, in a service that rewards the pursuit of mediocrity and punishes excellence.
Despite various ups and downs I eventually made it through my probation and started on what at one point looked like being a fairly successful career in Law Enforcement. Or as I saw it “Justice Enforcement” not necessarily synonymous!
I spent a certain amount of time on an interview team, (Part of what we shall call here CID, tough under the Dave Phillips model something far more surgical); there I worked for an Acting DS. I remember him as being very efficient thorough, a good interviewer, self possessed and extremely helpful to a young copper. He taught me a lot about case files and investigative procedure.
He was, however, not some one I stayed in touch with after I left. Today I was waiting to go off shore and I was trawling through the internet looking for old colleagues, and I typed my former Sergeant’s name into Google, looking I suppose for a Facebook Page or Linkedin or Myspace, to my shock I found a series of Articles about how he had been convicted of stabbing his wife, and was on the sex offenders register and had a rape conviction.
This forced me to reflect, it is often said that society gets the Police Force it deserves, and I wonder how true this is. Police Officers are notoriously subject to divorce, alcoholism, suicide, depression debt and addictive behavior, it comes with the territory. There was, in one of the articles, a photograph of my former DS, he was easily recognizable. What had made him like that? What had gone wrong? Was he some one who should never have been recruited or did the system make him then fail him? I do not know and I am not qualified to say, but I feel the question must be posed.
I read once that the difference between a Police officer and soldier is that a soldier deals with Violence, a Police Officer deals with the consequence of violence. In both cases the individual becomes desensitized.
The question remains though; are we asking too much of our Police officers? I recall one occasion where during a particularly nasty public order incident, I had quite literally been fighting for my life, I eventually overcame the offender. I can still feel the adrenalin pumpimg through my veins the uncontrollable twitching in my muscles as they spasmed whilst trying to reabsorb the life saving hormone and return me to normal. As soon as the cuffs clicked around the offenders wrists, an offender who moments before had been trying to stab me, I was required to calmly caution him, whereas every instinct in my body, based on millions of years of evolution wanted to drive his head through the tarmac and dispose of the threat once and for all. I remember tripping over the words of the caution, until an older and more experienced officer grabbed me by the arm (obviously realizing what I was going through) and walked me round the patrol car three times till I was calm enough to perform my duty correctly.
But what does that do to the mind and body? Adrenalin is a powerful substance evolved to power the fight or flight reflex, it raises the heart rate more effectively than any street corner amphetamine, and channels the blood flow of the body, narrows vision and impairs mental function, in short it turns us back in to the savages we once needed to be to survive.
Police Officers however are expected to go from this cloud of red mist to quiet professionalism in under a second. It’s like asking some one to drive a Ferrari a full speed into a brick wall and get out unscathed, it’s asking too much. Something, sooner or latter, will break.
I have no idea who or what broke my former DS, but next time you see a broken copper look beyond the self righteous indignation of the tabloids, and ask yourself, would you rather let the machine that is Law enforcement run as nature intended, in which case you might sleep peacefully in your beds, or should it be neutered/ emasculated (sorry about the gender specific) / and rendered safe and ineffective? A safe police Force is like a safe sword… Pointless.
It is a paradox, and one that reminds me of one of my favorite songs, “Sympathy with the Devil” Jagger belts out,
Every Cop is a criminal
And all the sinners saints”
And then summarizes so well
“ I shouted out, who killed the Kenedeys?
When after all
It was you and Me”
A suitable epitaph for the Blind Lady Who Stands atop the Old Baily,
“Sympathy For the Devil”
I wonder when they will pull her down, after all she is gender specific and quite clearly Caucasian?
R.I.P BRITISH POLICING